Home 
Members 
Friends Inviter 
Pages 
Polls 
Everybody has got at least 1 week for similar, so this will be 1 week for sure
Yep
110
Adrian GoodwinAG
Glenn OwensGO
Keith Griffin
Well, if he dodges that tackle, a bunch of players have been unfairly benched in the past few seasons.
Yep
Terry Adams
He was so done and just snapped. No buts about it. Hopefully he'll take that as a lesson.
Yep
Howard Brown
Yes, he was frustrated by two high tackles on him that were not penalized.
Yep
Craig SandersCS
Craig Sanders
He's definitely not the top dog. No clue how to take him down!
Yep
Allen Martin
Reid can learn from winning Best and Fairest.
Yep
Leroy Douglas
Just picture getting second place and not being the top player, like Mitchell and Cotchin's phony Brownlow win.
Yep
Adam Hawke
We already a dozen games deep. Who really thought he was gonna take the win? One injury and he might be benched. Let's just wrap the year up, ya know?
Yep
Phillip Williams
Was he the top dog? Maybe, but not exactly playing fair, just the runner-up. Deanna Turner
Yep
Luis Martin
It's like the Brownlow rules - if you can't go a season without breaking a rule, tough luck. It ain't a participation award like back in primary school. You gotta earn those top prizes by playing by the book. Easy as that.
Yep
Cynthia James
Fyfe shirked the rules but the AFL let him off the hook because he was the golden boy at the time, and he ended up winning the Brownlow Medal.
Yep
Michael Brown
Hey, rules are rules, so just let it go.
Yep
Kian Hickey
G'day mate, welcome to the top tier princess
Yep
Nick RombotisNR
Nick Rombotis
Who claimed he would win it from the start? Jeremiah Baker
Yep
26
5
4
4
4
3
54443...
Jackson Smith
The best is someone who follows the rules and excels.
Yep
Joel Kennedy
He is the top first-year player in the AFL and will be a future champion.
Yep
Thomas Peterson
Do you think fairness in the game is no longer important? All players, especially role models, should play with sportsmanship for the benefit of society and young fans. Being the best does not excuse you from facing consequences for your actions. Fairness is crucial.
Yep
Mark McNeil
Can't go changing the rules to make sure the player the AFL favors wins the award. It just doesn't fly like that.
Yep
Keiren Thompson
I think this kid is an absolute legend on the field, hands down the top rookie in the AFL! But hey, just remember, play around and you'll soon find out what happens! Jack Davis
Yep
14
3
2
2
2
2
32222...
Andrew Broadfoot
If someone's getting punished for no good reason in a report, they shouldn't have to deal with it. It's just not fair when one week a simple play gets you out for ages but the next week someone gets away with a way worse move. It's just not consistent. Hunter Kelly
Yep
17
4
4
3
3
1
44331...
Alastair Smith
Having a blast watching this youngster tear it up at Optus this year...he's all about the competition, taking on every ball like a champ. He's a total beast and couldn't care less about awards!
Yep
Riley Murray
Follow the rules and we all stay safe and sound!
Yep
Sam FitzPatrick
Starting in 2025, award the best player for both Rising Star and Brownlow without the fairest segment, without making immediate changes for just two individuals.
Yep
Scott Martin
Folks just don't get the diff between a rising star and the Brownlow for best and fairest, ya know?
Yep
Paul Bennett
Gotta be the top pick for MVP, no doubt.
Yep
Andrew Hipwell
Lori Harris
Yep
Liam Symons
Rules cannot be altered retrospectively.
Yep
Edward AndersonEA
Edward Anderson
Just make the Rising star the award for the fairest young player and have a different award for the best. You can't say fairer than that, mate! Geoff McCallum
Yep
13
4
3
2
2
1
43221...
Raymond Lee
As far as I know, the award was given to the player who worked hard all year. Katherine Hernandez
Yep
22
6
5
3
3
2
65332...
Tony FontanaTF
Tony Fontana
Ditch the award or just make it a MVP award. Suspensions are dropping left and right for no reason, it's getting out of control.
Yep
James Stewart
If it was someone else, there wouldn't be a drama. This media attention is causing more trouble than benefit.
Yep
Edward HebertEH
Edward Hebert
That tackle was straight up reckless. You gotta pay the price if you do the deed. And don't even get me started on that throat jab, that should be illegal too.
Yep
Joseph Russell
He is not the top player and talks back to the umpires. Anthony Jennings
Yep
13
4
3
2
1
1
43211...
Randy Anderson
Dusty had a case of beginner's bad luck in his first year!
Yep
Joshua Brown
Harley is ineligible for the rest of the season, and other clubs may start to imitate Windhager's tactics.
Yep
Harry Cooper
Everyone is accountable for their mistakes!
Yep
Justin Murphy
But mate, they're trying to crackdown on this type of tackle in the game, so why would you be getting praised for continuing to do it?
Yep
Dimitri Triantis
Prioritizing player safety, the rule of being ineligible if suspended is crucial, as the award is for the best and fairest, not just the best player. Katie Watkins
Yep
Allen Pyne
Are we really gonna bend the rules just cuz the homie got caught cheatin'? Take your L, grow from it, and bounce. Adam Wilson
Yep
16
4
3
3
2
2
43322...
Glenn OwensGO
Glenn Owens
You're like his own personal clubhouse and coach, but he needs to learn to own up to his errors. No more entitled attitude – time to take responsibility!
Yep
Adrian GoodwinAG
Adrian Goodwin
The top dog, so whoever takes the crown is the champ of the season.
Yep
Mark my words …. Mitchell is not playing State of Origin this year
Madge invited him, along with Cook and Walker, but he declined out of respect for Souths club and fans.
Cleary and his mates didn't rock up either, but let's just focus on Mitchell.
Trying to act like he doesn't want to play origin because he knows he won't be picked based on performance. Aaron Williams
There's no way we're putting that terrible fullback in before our top-notch centres!
It would do him mad good to spend some time in the NSW cup. That'll bring him back down to earth, ain't no way he's making the NSW Origin squad. Paula Gonzalez
Just stop putting him in the news, it's annoying for all of us. Instead, write about how he caused trouble for the NSW team by not singing the anthem with his little group. And that same group keeps using the NRL to complain about things unrelated to rugby league. Even JT had something to say about ... View More
Qld reckons you should chuck him in too! 😉 Andrew Wylie
Is Taylor Swift still on tour? I'd rather hear about her than hear about Mitchell chilling on his farm and not a care in the world. Edward Kelly
Can't resist, huh? You needed a little help getting more likes and comments, so you had to bring up Latrell's name again! But there was already an article today saying that he and the Rabbitohs players turned down the invitation, wanting to focus on their club instead. Right now, their team unity is... View More
